joining a commander

so i tried to join a commander who has less then 8 officers and i get "This is a big NO NO. What you are trying to do defies logic."


what does it mean?

k, will change the error message

basically the problem was that you would have created a commander loop which is not allowed

A joining B who joins C who joins A

Cannot join this commander, risk of creating a loop

but i do not see a loop....his co is not my officer so there should be no loop...

donais wrote:Cannot join this commander, risk of creating a loop

but i do not see a loop....his co is not my officer so there should be no loop...

I dont see a risk of a loop . my CO has a completely different CO . So there is no risk

Really?
you do realize a loop is still a loop even if there's 5-7 people in it instead of just 3

and if donais joined ishurue then there would be a loop

Admin wrote:Really?
you do realize a loop is still a loop even if there's 5-7 people in it instead of just 3

and if donais joined ishurue then there would be a loop

Basically if i want Donais i have to leave my CO . cuz thatle break the loop right ?

yap

So, you aren't allowing any loop no matter how big .. But I don't see how it would affect anything, due to its only RAW that affects teh CO. Unless i missed something.

You want a commander who is inferior to you in rank? It's like you being a general would take orders from a private....


Quote: "This is a big NO NO. What you are trying to do defies logic."

This makes sense.

Nigatsu_Aka wrote:
You want a commander who is inferior to you in rank? It's like you being a general would take orders from a private....


Quote: "This is a big NO NO. What you are trying to do defies logic."

This makes sense.

But in this sort of game rank doesn't really mean anything, a rank 200 player with a 5million army size is a bigger/better player then a rank 2 person with 900k Army... (These are just examples)

Alex wrote:

Nigatsu_Aka wrote:
You want a commander who is inferior to you in rank? It's like you being a general would take orders from a private....


Quote: "This is a big NO NO. What you are trying to do defies logic."

This makes sense.

But in this sort of game rank doesn't really mean anything, a rank 200 player with a 5million army size is a bigger/better player then a rank 2 person with 900k Army... (These are just examples)

I mean military rank not the silly number that you're refering too.
If you are the commander of someone, means that you have a higher military rank than him.

So if A>B>C then C cannot be bigger than A (again from the military rank point of view). I hope this helps you.

EDIT:
On a practical note, what you're suggesting is having a circle from which everyone can win extra 20% UU of RAW at no costs and if it was posible, trust me that it had been used since the begining.

Spoiler:

OK sorry I thought you were refering to the situation and players as above, saying that donias was trying to join someone who was lower ranked (Ingame rank), I didn't realise you were giving a 'real life' example of why CO circles might no be allowed. (As there arn't any 'ranks' in aderan, not in the same way there are ranks in the military anyway)

-Alex

I just love that iterative script to find out if a link would get created so much