Alliance bank

when the time is ripe, still need to consider some things

any movement on this

It will come when it's ready

This isn`t really needed, imo.
The reasons why i`m so reticent to this ideea are the possible abuses from: multies, scammers or "unfairplay players" (feeders if you want to call them that way).
But if you will add it, then put limits on size or huge upgrade costs and increased fees than on normal banking. That can still make it usefull, but will descourage the abuses (they can still be abused though with only taxes - so i`d rather not have it at all).

I personally agree with Nigatsu. Teamwork is one of the greatest things about these games, its what keep us here. Interaction with other people.

But alliance banks often end up being a place for inactives, and "friends" to put their resources for other players to use.

I am willing to work with anything, and I do know and understand that most everything is not a coding issue, but a player issue. Its all in how the players decide to play the game.

Agree with nomad or anyone else looking into the idea this way :-) of not allowing a bank. I will approve of a bank if it can not be abbused. sounds stupid maybe to some :-)

should only leader and 2ic or also advisers be able to accept withdraw requests?

Admin wrote:should only leader and 2ic or also advisers be able to accept withdraw requests?

I dont really care, its a two edge sword.

on one hand its easier the more people who can make things happen, but also more chance for confusion and mistakes.

not here

well there should be a control mechanism giving all members the right to see what was withdrawn and by whom. plus also who approved it

hehe, there's gonna be something much better

If you have a debt, you cannot withdraw anymore until you cover it. Add this:

how about having an alliance bank that only taxes the members that use it?
the % taken as payment for using it goes into another section similar to savings ina real bank, only this money CANNOT be withdrawn, instead a % of the alliance tax fund goes into the actual ingame market meaning the market grows also, the remainder of the kuwal gained through alliance bank taxation would then be autmatically allocated to the lowest ranked member within the alliance on a weekly basis, this way, if you dont want to pay an alliance tax you dont have to, but if you do you do so on the understanding that you will be paying a % of the kuwal deposited as a taxation for using that feature, this way, if you want to pay alliance tax, you can, and as abonus theres always a place to store excess kuwal (for when your bank is already full and need extra for that next level)
and if you dont want to pay alliance tax then you dont have to, but you also wont get use of the allaince bank....

should please some of those against the taxation....

there's not gonna be any taxation, that's for certain

I think that there should be a voluntary tax, which means that each member who wants to pay the tax will have to activate it. He/she will pay the tax for one week and must activate paying tax again before the week ends to pay for the tax in the next week.

It should be visible how much each member deposited and has withdrawn altogether (NET total = deposits - withdrawals), AND how many days the member paid the tax

The tax should be anywhere between 1% to 5% of the daily income (at the normal work condition) and be deducted 4 times a day. (Altogether 1%-5% of daily income would be paid each day)

The alliance should have the possibility to turn alliance taxing off.

Poll shows that 12 people are in favor of alliance banks and 12 people are against alliance banks in any form.
I guess we should have alliance taxing in a restricted manner so that the system can't be abused (much) and we improve gameplay.